15 Varieties of Homemade Cookies. Must pre-order by November 19 to guarantee availability. Limited options available if not pre-ordered. $5.50 per Dozen. Let us do the Holiday Baking for you. Pick up your Cookies on Dec 2nd from 1:00 to 7:00 pm or Dec 3rd from 9:00 am to Noon. Order forms available at the Chamber of Commerce, St Johns Church Searles, Cathedral Church, or St Mary's Church New Ulm.